Radioactivity well logging system



Nov. l0, 1953 S. A. SCHERBATSKOY RADIOACTIVITY WELL LOGGING SYSTEM Filed July 5, 1951 6 Sheets-Sheet l Boro/z S/zz/c Para @dal S. A. SCHERBATSKOY RADIOACTIVITY WELL LOGGING SYSTEM Nov. 10, 1953 6 Sheets-Sheet 2 Filed July 5, 1951 llllllllllllllllllllllllll Nov. 10, 1953 s. A. scHERBATsKoY RADIOACTIVITY WELL LoGcING SYSTEM Filed July 5, 1951 6 Sheets-Sheet 3 I llllll I IQWHINWNMWSIW UWNQMWNMWNI MNMNNMMI I lm wm, o o o OQQWN. n IO m@ l, @mi @S NMS w EQ n m o no o o x( Sv Rw. n. WIM www .N o o I I I I l I I I INI I I I |.I IIIIIIIIIIII I L H ,est \N.\. l I I I I I I l l lmmwmwmbmwwlgmmmwwvmwlwml m um m 0 S KSO QPQ. ||I||.|| 0N u O NQ @N QS vm NNIUQ@ n o 2mm Q o o wm Q IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I I I &\

INVENTOR.

S, A. SCHERBATSKOY RADIOACTIVITY WELL LOGGIING SYSTEM Nov. 1o, 1953 6 Shee'cs-SheefI 4 Filed July 5 19451 NRN wwmmwlwwmml 1 NOV- 10, 1953 s. A. ScHERBATsKoY RADIOACTIVITY WELL LOGGING SYSTEM 6 Sheets-Sheet 5 Filed July 5. 1951 RQ NUM. f, Qmmw.

1 1111 IIWWUNMNMNMWNMW ...Nmwvlww NOV- 10, 1953 s. A. scHERBATsKoY 2,659,014

RADIOACTIVITY WELL LOGGING SYSTEM Filed-July 5, 1951 s sheets-sheet e Patented Nov. 10, 1953 Ti-ENT" OFFICE RADIOAGTIVITY WELL LOGGING-SYSTEM- SergeA. Scherbatskoy, 'Jiulsa,f0kla.,i assig-rliorrltow Perforating Guns Atlas. .Corp )ration,-y Houston,... Tex., a corporation ofDelaware Application J uly 5; 1951, SerialiNoi2353300-r 21 Claims; (Cl. 2511-835) aradi'oactivity well loggingv system for simulta- Y neously` obtaining a neutron log and a gamma ray;- logof ,a borehole. Specifically, the. .present .inventionsrelates to. an improvement off the' radio.- activity well'logging, system. described in myI United States Patent No. 2,349,2251which issued on` May 16,l 19441 The. radioactivity well logging system discussed ini my prior patent identified above, isdesigned toproduce at the earthsv surface apermanent record ofY one type of radioactivity encountered by lai subsurface exploratory unit .which may be loweredfinto the borehole. Essentially, this well loggingY system comprisesa follow-up, or servo system which is used to: measure atthe earths surface-the output of a radiation detectorv posi-- tioned within the subsurface exploratory unit which latter unit is preferablyV supported by a. single conductor cable. Measurement of the radiation'- detector output is .accomplished by transmitting an alternating current signal rep-` resentative of the detector output tothe earths surfaceltogether with a reference signal of fixed'4 phase, adjusting the arm of a slide wire potenti-A ometer at the earths surface in accordance with the alternating current signal and 'feeding back;

a unidirectional signal to the subsurface unit which is proportional to the position. of the arm:

of the 4potentiometer to balance or matchvthe detector output thereby bringing the system to a null'l or balance point. As the detector output varies the system follows by readjusti'ng the arm ofthe potentiometer by the propervamount and iir the proper direction to. cause thefeedback. potentia-l to exactly equalA the detector output Vand rebalance the system. The position of the arn'r` of the-potentiometer is thus an accurate indicationl ofthe detector output and may be usedl to produce a permanent record of the radioactivity encountered by the subsurface unit.

While the above described-well loggingsystem is vsai'i'sfactory for obtaining a; log v of y"one typeof racliatitm,` and, in fact, is highly desirable.fromy the vstandpoint of accuracy,Y it is in many instances necessary to combine two -types` of -radioactivity logs. Forexample, it is necessary to combine a gamma ra-y log and a neutron log in order that the stratigraphy and possible pay .Inxidition.tofthe production of gammaray;v

and vneutron-1ogs,it isalso necessary to obtain accurate; depth` measurements, both for the-.pur posenofcorrelating thetwo logs and for the pun` poser of icheckingc-previous depth measurements.r Of the-conventionalxdepth measurement methodsavailable, the...collar logging method is generallyconsideredthe most accurate;v such devices-as the depth-.measuring sheave; etc., being inaccuratel`- duetostretchingofthe supporting cable as an apparatus. is lowered into the borehole. It would bev desirable..therefore,.to provide facilities for.`

obtaining a simultaneousneutron and: gammaA ray logtogether-withacollar position log, while employing-.ahighaccuracy follow-up system suchy as descrilzredy above; for-each of the radioactivity logs.,y

Furthermore, it is;.desirable to provide the above described; simultaneous well logging system: while employing only a single;l conductor armored cablev toiraiseandlower'the equipment, to supply power. tothe subsurface; unitand to transmit all of. they loggingsignals between; the subsurfacev equipment andithezsurface. equipment. Such a cablel is... easy toi handle; is inexpensive, and may be constructed.- to. withstand. the weight of. many.

thousandsof .feet of. its .own length.

Accordinglmitis an .object ofthe presentvine vention to provide a new and improved radio-.-

activity .welllogging system for simultaneously producing. a neutron. log anda gamma ray logof system are transmitted to the earths surfaceover a .single cable, preferably comprising asingle 1 insulated conductor..

It isa further'obje'ct of the present invention to. provide. a `new and improved well logging sys-` temzfor simultaneously producing a combinedr neutron, gamma ray and collar position log;

wherein each of the radioactivity logs is obtained bymeans.. of la self-balancing follow-up systems and' allof. the logging signals are transmitted `to the earths surface over a single cable preferably comprising arisingle 4insulated conductor.

Itiisa stillfurther object of the present virl-'- vention to provide a newvand improved-welilog#l ging systemffor simultaneously obtaining a Acom bined neutronandgamma ray 10g wherein each of` the logs is obtained by means of a self-balancing slicieWire'potentiometersystem,v and wherein, all

of the signals of both systems are transmitted to the earths surface by a single cable, preferably comprising a single insulated conductor, and wherein the single conductor cable is also used to supply power to the subsurface equipment and to transmit collar position information to the earths surface.

Briey, according to one phase of the invention, the subsurface exploratory unit is provided with rst and second ionization chambers adapted respectively to produce unidirectional ionization currents proportional to gamma rays intercepted by the unit and neutrons intercepted by the unit. The gamma ray channel is substantially as described in my prior patent described above and includes facilities for transmitting an alternating current proportional to the gamma ray detector output and a fixed phase reference signal which is modulated on a higher frequency carrier over the supporting cable to the earths surface and for feeding back a unidirectional balancing potential over the cable to the subsurface unit to bring the system to a null or balance point. The neutron channel includes facilities for transmitting an alternating current of a different frequency from that of the gamma ray signal and representative of the neutron detector output and a fixed phase reference signal modulated on a carrier wave of diiferent frequency from that of the gamma ray carrier over the supporting cable to the earths surface. The feedback signal for the neutron channel may be transmitted back over the supporting cable in one of two ways. In the first embodiment the neutron feedback signal comprises a pulse wave having an amplitude and polarity representative of the position of the arm of the neutron slide wire potentiometer. In the second embodiment the neutron feedback signal comprises a rst alternating current of a frequency different from the remaining signals of the system and a fixed phase reference signal which is modulated on a carrier wave of still another frequency. As either the gamma ray and neutron ionization current changes, the corresponding slide wire potentiometer at the earths surface is readjusted so as to bring the channel associated therewith to a null or balance point.

In accordance with another aspect of the invention, a simplified system is provided in which the use of feedback signals is eliminated. In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, collar position information is also transmitted over the supporting cable in the form of unidirectional voltage fluctuations or kicks which are detected at the earths surface to provide a combined gamma ray, neutron and collar position log.

The invention, both as to its organization and method of operation, together with further objects and advantages thereof, will best be understood by reference to the following specification taken in connection with the accompanying drawings in which:

Fig. 1 diagrammatically illustrates a simultaneous radioactivity well logging system characterized by the features of the present invention;

Fig. 2 is a schematic diagram of one embodiment of the subsurface equipment of the present improved logging apparatus;

Fig. 3 is a schematic diagram of one embodiment of the surface equipment of the present improved logging apparatus;

Figs. 4 and 5 are schematic diagrams Qf all* 4 other embodiment of the subsurface and surface equipments, respectively, of the present improved logging apparatus;

Fig. 6 diagrammatically illustrates an alternative simultaneous radioactivity well logging sys tem of the present invention; and

Fig. '7 is a timing diagram used in explaining. the operation of the system of Figs. 2 and 3.

Referring now to the drawings and more particularly to Fig. 1 thereof, the simultaneous neutron, gamma ray and collar position logging apparatus there illustrated generally comprises a subsurface unit IO and a surface unit I I interconnected by means of a single conductor coaxial cable I2. The arrangement illustrated is particularly adapted for the simultaneous productionv of high accuracy neutron and gammaV ray logs of boreholes traversed by the subsurface unit Ill.

In general, the subsurface equipment Ill comprises a collar nder circuit 24, a gamma ray detector 25, power and signal translating circuits 26, a neutron detector 21, a boron shield 28, a paraiiin spacer 29 and a mass of lead 30 within which is positioned a suitable neutron source Sila.

The component units 24 to 30, inclusive, are all housed within a sealed housing having the requisite physical strength to withstand the fluid pressures encountered and are preferably located in the housing in the particular order illustrated. The unit I0 is arranged to be lowered into the borehole by means of the cable I2 which preferably is of the coaxial type and comprises a center conductor I3 surrounded by and insulated from an armored sheath I4. This sheath is appropriately grounded at the earths surface and an alternating current generator I'I, forming a part of the surface equipment II and coupled to the cable conductor I3 through the blocking condenser I8, is utilized to supply power over the cable I2 to the subsurface unit IIJ. As will be understood by those skilled in the art, the cable I2 extends into the borehole and is carried on a suitable power operated drum I5 located at the earths surface. Conventional drive facilities may be provided for rotating the drum I5 in either direction, whereby the cable I2 may be fed into or reeled out of the borehole so as to move the subsurface equipment IB longitudinally of the borehole. In the particular arrangement illustrated in Fig. l, the bore hole is lined with the usual ferrous metal casing I6 which is provided with collar coupling elements, not shown, along the length thereof. These elements have the effect of increasing the wall thickness of the casing at evenly spaced points along the length of the casing and hence serve as casing section markers.

Generally considered, the surface equipment II comprises a gamma ray detector channel I9, a neutron detector channel 25J, a collar finder detector circuit 2| and a recorder 22 which is preferably of the commercial type known as the Speed-O-Max manufactured by the Leeds & Northrup Co. of Philadelphia, Pa. Specifically, the output circuits of the units I9 and 2d are connected to the recording instrument 22 which operates to produce on the record strip 22a, a continuous graph of both the neutron and gamma ray signals transmitted to the surface equipment II from the subsurface equipment if). The recorder 22 also responds to signals from the detector circuit 2| to produce record indications on the strip 22a identifying the positions of the casing collars so that a correlated neutron,

gamma ray anddepth measurement logisch-f: tained.

Brieiiy tor consider the general mode ofoperation ofthe vsimultaneous-.loggings .rsystemshown in Fig. 1 without consideringin detailthe circuit arrangements of the units shown, therein'. in block diagram form, the gamma ray detectorv rintercepts and.' detects gamma radiation einaf natingfrom the subsurfacematerial surrounding the borehole. Preferably, the-,gamma ray de@ tector 25 is .in .the form of .anionzation charnber. which conventionally consistsof a cylinder, containing two.A insulated electrodes.. and.. filled.. withan inert lgas under high pressure. Under, normal'conditions, the high insulating properties. of the gas keep any current from lo'wingwhen an electrical potential is applied between. the` elec: trodes. However, when th'e chamber is sub.- jected to gamma radiation, the actionof the gamma rays on the. molecules of the gas is such as to cause. partial ionization, an Aelectrical phef nomenon which' results in a smallelectrical current flowing between the electrodes.'A The magnitude of this current ispropjortionalto'the inf tensity of thegamma rays entering `the chamber..

The unidirectional ionization current produced by the gamma ray ionization chamberl25- is measured by means of a null balance orfollow-r up system which includes a self-balancing potentiometer of the inverter type. Morespecificallm. the voltage difference between the output of thev ionization chamber 25 andthe Voltage which. exists across a feedback circuit Yload impedance. in the subsurface unit llis derived andjis conf verted into a '75 cycle per second signal, which nay be termed an alternating. current error .siga nal and which is transmitted to the surface vover the single conductor of the. cable i2.". A.75"cycle alternating current reference signal of. fixed.Y

paraffin spacer. 29...and theboron shield 28..are.V provided .with-.aree positionedbetween the.. source. 30a.. andthe ,neutrondetector 21.. The. detailsj.of.' the paraflin-boron shield: between. the.. neutron. 5., source and the neutron detector are described in"v detail\ in my. copending. application. Serial No. 205,616, led Januar`y1`2,.1951. 'Howeven for purposesofjthe present disclosure, it may.v be statedthatthe paraiiinandlb'oron shield isprovidedto. prevent the. direct transmission of vneutrons .from ,thesource .392i tothe neutron detecto'r 2.'l.ls"c' `.that lthe neutrons fromI the" source alla.l mustltravel through the., surrounding.. formation. and enter .theneutron detector Riina direction.

.at leastpartially lateral.. tov the `axis of the..

borehole.

The. neutron, detector 21 ispreferably of the,

ionization chamber type and is substantially.` identicaltothegamma ray detector 25. How'- `ever,.in.order todetect neutrons .which travel fromlthe source. 30a. through the surrounding. formation to. the detector 2l, this detector. is@

encased in or coated with a composition ofmaterials consisting of or comprising elements,.

such as cadmium, which havethe property of absorbing neutrons, particularly neutrons whosevelocity has. been reduced by passage througha medium comprisinglow atomic weight elements such as' hydrogen, and of emitting so-calledf vgamma rays of capture in proportion to the.

ray detector channel. However', the alternating current error signal is of a different frequency, preferably 40 cycles, .and thee() cycle phaserefphase position is also produced 'in the'subsurface'. 40 erencesignal is modulated upon a carrier wave unit lil` and is modulated` upon .a.5'70cycle..car. rier wave, the modulated carrier wave also being... transmitted to the earths surface over thesinglel conductor of the cable I2".` Thej75fcyclerefererence signal is demodulated inthe gamma...rajy, detector channel leand is comparedwthth'e. '.75 cycle error signal inv a ring modulatorcireui't. so as to provide a unidirectiOnaLgarnma.ray er:

ror signal'indicative of the vunbalance of'.r the.. system. The unidirectionalgamma..ray. error.- signal is supplied to the recorderv 22Jwl'1ereinv it is used to actuate the arm. of.'a balanced slidel wire potentiometer, andtocontrol theposition.. of a recording pen. A source .of unidirectional potential is connected across. the gamma ray', slide wire potentiometer andthe-` potential Aat the arm of the.potentiometerised.back love'rthe.Y

The neutron detector 2l functions` todetcct 7a rate thereof.

neutrons which are induced in Athe surrounding. formation and returned' tothe. detector inresponse to irradiation of the formation byf the.- neutrons emitted from the sourcela. In orderY of diierentfrequency, preferably a frequency of 250 cycles.' In order to provide a simultaneous neutron and gamma ray'logg'ing system whilev .45 sary to provide different facilities for feeding back asignal to the subsurface unit l!! to balance the neutron null point system. This will be readily understood when it is realizedthat the gamma ray channel employs a unidirectional.

feedback potential and, if both systemswere to feed back unidirectional potentials over the same conductor, the two unidirectional voltages would interfere with. each other andcauseimproper operation of each channel.`

In accordancewith the Ypresent invention, si. multaneous neutron and gannna ray logging is. accomplished by modifying the feedback signal of either one of the channelsso thatit will'not interfere with. the feedback signal of the other .6g channel. Furthermore, alternative modifications of the feedback signal may be employed. In the illustrated..v embodiments, of the invention, the

neutronchannel is modified and in the system of Figs. 2 and 3 .one particular systemv is shown. In .this 'embodiment a pulse type of feedback signal is employed. More specifically, a pulse generatoris connectedacross the neutron slide wire potentiometer, the pulses therefrom having. a time .duration which is alsmall .fraction of the recurrence Preferably, the frequency ofthe pulses vis relatively high', being of the. order of 1,0001t'o.2;000cyclesper second.V The portion of the pulse', generator output which appears between the arm of the neutron slidewire potentiometer` to improve the quality ofthe neutron 1og, tlfe`..75 land ground 'is fed'backov'cruthe cable lzltothe subsurface unit I wherein the pulses are rectied to produce a unidirectional balancing potential which is supplied to the feedback load impedance to balance out the neutron detector output and thus balance the system.

In the alternative system shown in Figs. 4 and 5, an 800 cycle sine wave generator is connected across the neutron slide wire potentiometer and the portion of the 800 cycle generator output which appears between the arm of the potentiometer and ground is fed back over the cable I2 to the subsurface unit ID. An 800 cycle fixed phase reference signal derived from the 800 cycle generator is modulated upon a carrier wave of relatively high frequency, preferably of the order of 4500 cycles per second, and the modulated carrier wave is also fed back over the cable I2 as a phase reference signal. In the unit IB, the two 800 cycle signals are compared in a ring modulator circuit to derive a unidirectional balancing potential which is applied to the neutron feedback load impedance to balance the neutron detector output and bring the neutron channel toa balanced or null condition.

In the subsurface unit I0, the collar finder circuit 24 functions to produce a unidirectional voltage deflection, or kick, each time the unit i5 traverses a casing collar and these voltage kicks are supplied over the conductor I3 to the surface equipment II. The unidirectional voltage collar finder kicks are separated from the other signals present on the cable conductor i3 in the collar finder detector circuit 2I and are supplied to the recorder 22. There is thus produced simultaneously with the gamma ray and neutron logs on the record strip 22a a correlated collar position log so as to provide correlated depth measurement.

Considering now the detailed circuit arrangement of the system shown in Figs. 2 and 3, and as discussed above in connection with the general system arrangement of Fig. 1, the subsurface unit I0 performs the functions of supplying correlated neutron, gamma ray and collar position signals over the conductor I3 to the surface equipment I I as the subsurface unit I is moved longitudinally of the borehole. The power and signal translating circuits 26 of the subsurface unit i5 include the power supply circuit 33 (Fig. 2), the gamma ray signal channel 3I and the neutron signal channel 32. The gamma ray channel 3! includes a condenser-commutator indicated generally at 35, an amplifier 33, a modulator it and a 570 cycle oscillator 52. The neutron signal channel 32 is in many respects similar to the gamma ray signal channel 3! and includes a condenser commutator 4", an amplifier 48, a modulator 50, a 250 cycle oscillator 52 and a pulse rectier circuit 55. The collar finder circuit 2G is also shown in detail in Fig. 2 of the drawings.

rI'he power supply circuit 33 receives alternating current power from the generator il over the cable I2 and includes facilities for converting the same to a unidirectional supply voltage which is suitable for energizing the radiation detectors and 2l and the circuit components of the gamma ray signal channel 3| and the neutron signal channel 32. While the power supply circuit 33 may be of any desired configuration, it is preferred to employ a power supply circuit of the type described and claimed in my above identified copending application Serial No. 205,616. VJhile reference may be had to this application for a detailed description of the power supply circuit 33, for purposes ofthe present disclosure it may be stated that a 400 cycle power wave is supplied from the generator I1 to the power supply circuit 33, wherein a power transformer and rectifier circuit is provided to supply rectified and filtered high voltage to the ionization chambers 25 and 21 over the conductor 60 and to provide a relatively low, rectified and filtered anode potential which is supplied over the conductor 52 to the vacuum tubes of the gamma ray and neutron signal channels 3| and 32. Preferably, the power supply circuit includes means for preventing harmonics of the rectified voltage from appearing on the conductor I3 and furthermore provides a balanced type of operation whereby the output potentials of the power supply circuit 33 do not vary appreciably with large changes in ambient temperature, as described in detail in my copending application identied above.

Considering rst the gamma ray logging portion of the system of Figs. 2 and 3, and more particularly the gamma ray signal channel 3|, the electrodes of the gamma ray ionization chamber 25 are energized by the high voltage supplied thereto over the conductor 60 and there is produced across the series connected output resistors 65 and 66 thereof a unidirectional voltage which is proportional to the intensity of gamma ray radiation intercepted by the ionization chamber 25. In order to measure at the earths surface the potential drop across the resistor 66, and hence to obtain an indication of the gamma ray intensity as the subsurface unit I0 is moved up and down within the borehole, a null balance or follow-up system is provided which includes the condenser commutator circuit 35, the amplifier 38, the modulator 40, the oscillator 42 and certain components of the surface equipment to be described in more detail hereinafter. More particularly, the condenser commutator circuit 35 is employed to measure the Voltage difference between the voltage existing across the ionization chamber output resistor 66 and a feedback load resistor 'I0 and to convert this voltage difference into a so-called error signal having a frequency of 75 cycles per second. The condenser commutator 35 may be of the type described in detail in my prior Patent No. 2,349,225, and reference may be had to this patent for a detailed description of such a condenser commutator. However, for purposes of the present disclosure, it may be stated that the condenser commutator 35 includes a fixed commutator plate 'I2 which is electrically connected through the feedback load resistor 1I) to ground and a movable commutator plate 'I3 which is electrically connected through the resistor 66 to ground. A carbon button I4 is contiguous to one end of the movable plate 'I3 and the plate 13 acts as an armature in a buzzer type circuit under the influence of a solenoid coil 'I5 which is energized from the power supply unit 33. The solenoid 15 is broadly tuned to resonance at a center frequency of 75 cycles per second by means of the condenser 'I1 which is connected from the solenoid 'I5 to ground. Likewise, a condenser I8 is connected across the carbon button 'I4 to reduce switching transients thereacross. The primary winding of a coupling transformer 8G is connected between the solenoid 'I5 and the carbon button 14.

The solenoid 15, current supply source 33, the primary winding of the coupling transformer and the carbon button 14, are all in series circuit relation, so that as the carbon button is compressed by motion of the commutator plate 'I3 away from the solenoid l5, the current from the current supply-source 1increases; thus tending to return. ther commutatorplatevv` 'I3 .to` its former position. Asthe .platelreturnsfthe pressure on the carbon button.is.reduced,.thereby reducing the currentand lesseningthepullon the solenoid on themovable plate-:13.V Therrequency at which the movable .plate 'IS-yibrates is determined-in part by the massandcomplianceofthe movable plate 'I3 and, as statedabove,vin 4the illustrated embodiment theVv condensencommutator 35 is adjusted to operate ata frequency of 75 cycles per second. K

As the movable Yplate -'I3 vibratesthe -capacity between the platesc12fand 13| undergoes ajcyclic variation andiiY the.-poterkitialsI across -the resistors 66 and 'l0 are not `equal,a-'75k cycle voltage is producedY at the-term inalpoint 61, the amplitude of which is equal-.to the voltage dierence between the ungrounded` ends of ythe-resistors 66 and 'i0 and thev phase-of which variesraccordA ing to the relative polarities ofthe voltages across these resistors. .Thusr-if the potential/across the-v resistor 66 is greater than theA potential across the resistor 10, a positively phased '75 cycle error voltage is produced aty the terminal point 61. u

On the other hand, yrif-'the voltage across the resistor iis less than. .the lresistor y, a 75 cycle error signal ofV theV opposite phasel is produced at the terminal 6T.`

In order to. providea-xed phase reference signal, so that the above described changes in phase of the 75 cycleerror signal may be detected at the earths surfacefthe V'75 cycle energizing current, whichows through the solenoid 'I5 and is of xed phase and` amplitude; is coupled through the transformer to the modulator d0. In the modulatorll. the '15 cycle-reference signal is modulated upon a 570 cycle carrier wave derived from the osci1lator`42. The modulator 40 and oscillator 42'may comprise A`any' circuit arrangement which is suitable for superimposing the 75 cycle reference phase signal as a modulation component on a high frequency carriery wave. For example, the modulator Il()v andosci1lator-ll2 damped Wave train, the phase relationship ofv the` 75 cycle modulationbears a fixed time relationship to the movements of thecommutator' plate '13. This modulation lcomponent consti` tutes a xed phase# reference signal which is transmitted over the-conductor I3 to the surface equipment(l l The 75 cycle errorsignal'pr'oduced at'the'tercomprise any 'suitablfcircuit arrangement for;-

amplifying the 75. cycle '.error signaL -to 'Mierde-- sired level.- For examplefan amplifier such as shown-in=-my2prior patent identied-above, 'may bewemployedrv y pC'onsideringwnowgthe embodiment `ofy-g-the surface lequipment-1| I shownlffin- Adetail -in Figi V-ol kthe drawings-this equipmentvperforms Vthe func-'- tionsA of Y separating" P,theV signals which .are transmitted-thereto fromith-e cablek I2; and fof i simulL taneously producing a continuous and?perma-v nent :record fof; l-correlated gamma rayV fand-f' neutronjlactivity and collanposition location in the borehole? Referring? tov this gure,` signals whichgfare supplied over `the Aconductor iI 3 lto zth'e surface equi-pmentil Igiare coupledxtorthe gamma; raydetector; channel-f FI 0,# the neutron "detector channel '20;jandfthe collar nder detector circuit 2I-'.; The ,-gamaray ydetector channell I8 `ofi-thev surfacemequipment I'Ycomprises `a 75 cycle band passflterg, :an amplier |3|;a 570 'cycle'rband passV lter: -I 60; an 'iamplier I 6 It, i a .detectorll |32l and -ga-ringemodulator,V circuitv |405v The? 75 cycle lgarifima.-'ray error ysignal which His transmittedover thercable I2 to=the1surface,f is separated from allaothe lremaining signalsvpresent on thecableconductor` I3 in theband passtlter |30. 2 TheY band -pass` lter I 30 I may comprise :any l suitablejelectric -wavezlterj "for separating: `the` 'I5A cycle error signalffrom the remaining 'sigr'rals" off the circuit. However,; the -lter |30 should have a suicientlysharp cuteoi characteristicto'" rejectthe adjacentfflfcycle neutron error signal."V The-separated 75 cycle errorsignal is amp1i ed by the ampli-fier |31" to :a :suitable .level and" coupledy through'the gtransformer |32 -to"-the"` ring- :modulator` vcircuit indicated generallyl iat. |120.'Y Thefvring modulator circuit comprisesal series:` of four rectiers |013 I 42, r I i3 Vand I 44'; all of which lare connected inV a :series `loop 'with the* same polarity around r-theloop V"tot "provideVv a'l modified bridge -Vcircuit arrangement.` 1 A rvseriesz circuit including- :the .resistors |33i and s |34wis connected acrossy the secondary `of-jthe "trans-f former |32 and the voltage across these resistors" isysuppliled to one'pair of diametrically opposed terminals of theimodulator' |40; A secondseries circuitfincludingthegresistors I 481 and |49 iscon-f' nected acrosslthe-other pair of diametrically op'- posed terminalsofxthemodulator I40and a rllter condenser |501isfconnectedfacross the resistorsy |8-1andca|49i i f In order to Aseparate the `5'70V cycle `carrier wave onf; Whichisxmodulatedrthe '75'l cycle gammay lray f referencesignal"l from 'fthe otherL signals@ of* the systemfthere is "provided: the band pass lter' I 60* junctiontpoint between the resistors |33' and l134" andi toffthe'fju'riction Illt'and HSS-.1-

ent,Y a -unidirectional'yoltage is producedacro'ss the-condenser |50'which is proportional fto the amplitude of the error signal. If the phase of Lpoint between the resistors-1 -referencesignalFis/suppliedit 7 thef-mordulator'|40- andfnoz'l cycle-` error "signa is suppliedthereto l'from the amplier'f 31;" the' modulator f'outputf'isfsbalanceizl'l sof that 'nolout putf'voltageigis rproduced :across :the -condenserff' |50. However, if a 75 cycle error signalfisprsei 11 the 75 cycle error signal changes, the ring modulator |40 'produces'a unidirectional'utput'volt age of the opposite polarity and of an amplitude proportional to the amplitude ofthe error signal. The ring modulator |40 thus produces a unidirectional output voltage Which is accurately representative of the voltage difference between the resistors |66 and |10 in the subsurface unit I0.

TheV unidirectional output voltage from the modulator |40 is connected to one pair of input terminals of the recorder 22. In the illustrated embodiment, the recorder 22 is of the dual type and includes a gamma ray Vrecording pen and a neutron recording pen |80. The recorder 22 is also provided With slide Wire potentiometer circuits which are controlled in accordance with the respective gamma ray and neutron inputs to the recorder, and Which may be energized by external potential sources. 22 is provided with a rst slide Wire potentiometer circuit |12 which includes the series connected resistors |13 and |14 and the slide wire potentiometer |15 Which is connected across the resistors |13 and |14. of the resistors |13 and |14 is connected to ground, and a Voltage from an external unidirectional potential source, indicated by the battery |16, is connected across the series connected resistors |13 and |14 and the shunt connected slide Wire potentiometer |15 With the polarity shown in Fig. 3. As the position of the arm |11 of the potentiometer |15 is varied in accordance With the movement of the gamma ray recording pen |10, a variable unidirectional Voltage is produced. For example, if the arm |11 is at exactly the mid point 'of the potentiometer |15, the potential of the arm |11 with respect to ground is zero. If the arm is moved to the right, a positive potential with respect to ground is produced and if the arm is moved to the left, a negative potential With respect to ground is produced.

The arm |11 of the slide Wire potentiometer |15 is connected to the central conductor |3 of the cable |2 so that the voltage produced at the arm |11 is fed back over the cable |2 to the subsurface equipment I. In the subsurface equipment I0 the unidirectional feedback potential is supplied through the resistor 1| to the resistor 10 in the gamma ray signal channel 3|, so as to change the potential across the resistor 10 in the correct direction to balance the potential across the resistor 66 and thus balance the gamma ray system. If, now, the output current from the gamma ray detector which flows through the resistor 66 increases, a positively phased 15 cycle Verror signal is produced at the terminal 61 which is amplified in the amplifier 38 and transmitted to the surface equipment together with a fixed phase 75 cycle reference signal Which is modulated on the 570 cycle carrier Wave, to readjust the setting ofthe gamma ray slide Wire potentiometer |15, and a unidirectional feedback current is fed back from the potentiometer |15 to the resistor 10. which balances the increased detector output current. The system is thus brought to a balance or null condition in Which condition no potential difference exists between the commutator plates 12 and 13 and no 75 cycle error signal is transmitted over the conductor I3 to the surface equipment. Y

On the other hand, if the ionization current through the resistor 66 decreases, a Ynegatively Thus, the recorder The common junction phased 7,5, wel@ errlfsignal is. producedwhchis transmitted to the surface equipment to effect movement of the potentiometer |15 in the opposite direction and the unidirectional feedback current is correspondingly reduced by an amount such that the voltages across the resistors 66 and 1G are again equalized. From the Vforegoing discussion, it is evident that the above described follow-up system of measurement provides a means for transmitting information relative to the changes in the amplitude and polarity of the voltage across the resistor 66 While employing a single conductor cable.

Considering now the neutron signal channel 32 (Fig. 2), the neutron ionization chamber 21 produces a unidirectional ionization current which Flows through the series connected output resistors 39 and 5) thereof. The condenser commutator circuit is substantially identical with the condenser commutator of the gamma ray signal channel 3|, except for the fact that the condenser commutator 45 is designed to operate at a frequency of cycles per second. The commutator is used to develop a 40 cycle error signal Which is proportional in amplitude and phase to the diiference in voltage produced across the resistor 90 and a feedback load resistor Si. The 40 cycle error signal is amplied in the amplifier i8 and transmitted over the cable conductor i3 to the surface equipment. lso a 40 cycle reference signal is produced in the commutator circuit Which is coupled through the transformer 92 to the modulator 50 wherein it is superimposed upon a 250 cycle carrier wave pro-duced by the 250 cycle oscillator 52. The modulator and the oscillator 52 may comprise any desired circuit arrangement suitable for producing a 250 cycle carrier wave having the 40 cycle xed phase reference signal superimposed thereon. For example, the modulator 53 and oscillator 52 may be substantially identical to the modulator 40 and oscillator 42 described in detail above in connection with the gamma ray signal channel 3|; The 40 cycle reference signal which is superimposed upon the 250 cycle carrier Wave is also transmitted over the conductor i3 to the surface equipment.

-Considering noW the neutron detector channel 2Q in the surface equipment (Fig. 3), this channel comprises a 4G cycle band pass filter |90, an amplifier lill, a- 250 cycle band pass filter |95, an ampiier i9", a detector |91, a ring modulator circuit |92, and a pulse generator |98. The ll0 cycle error signal which is produced by the neutron signal channel 32 in the manner described above, is transmitted over the cable |2 to the neutron detector channel 20 and is separated from the other signals present on the cable conductor |3 by the band pass filter |90. The band pass nlter |50 may comprise any suitable circuit arrangement for separating the 40 cycle error signal, and preferably has a sufciently sharp cut-,off characteristic to reject the adjacent cycle error4 signal associated with the gamma ray signal channel 3|.,y The 40 cycle error signal is amplified by the amplier |9| to a suitable level and is suppliedto the ring modulator circuit |92. In circuit configuration, the

ring modulator circuit |92 is identical with the v ring modulator circuit |45 described in detail above in connection with the gamma ray decable `conduictor `I3'b`yvthe band 'pass l'ter IE5 which'has a -center pass frequency of 250 cycles. The separated Z50-cycle modulated carrier wave is then amplied in the amplifier lil'and supplied 'to the detector |91 wherein the carrier wave is dernodulatedto provide a 40 cycle phase reference signal which is supplied to the ring modulator circuit Isf.' The ring modulator circuit: I 92' functions in the same manner as the modulator Muto-produce a unidirectional control voltage which is accurately representative of the voltage difference between the resistors 90 and 9| in the neutron signal channel $2.- This unidirectional control voltageis supplied over the conductor I99to one-of 'the-input circuits of the dual recorder 22 and is used to control the position of the neutron recording pen |80.

In order'to provide a feedback potential for the neutron channel which can be applied to the feedback load resistor Sri to balance the potential across the resistor Si), while not conflicting with the unidirectional feedback potential which is fed over the conductor I3 tothe gamma ray signal channel 3| in the manner described above, a pulse type of feedback signal is derived from the pulse generator |98.- More specifically, the pulse generator ISS-produces pulses having substantially the. wave form shown in Fig. 7. As there shown, the pulses ii have a time duration t which is -a small fraction of the total period T between: pulses. Furthermore, the repetition rate ofthepulse is relatively high, preferably in the order of 1,000 to 2,000 cycles pensecond. The output from the pulse generator |98 vis suppliedlto a-neutron-slide wire potentiometer circuit vindicated generally at |32 in Fig. .3; The `circuit i* |82 includes the series connected. resistors |83 and ISII which are conneotedsacross a neutron-:slide wire potentiometer-.|85 The pulsey generator |98 is connected acrossA the potentiometer |85 and the junction point of the resistors IBB-and VI84-is connected to ground. so that there is produced between the arm I8? .of the potentiometer |85 and ground the pulses Ililhavingan amplitude A (Fig. 7) which varies in accordance with the position of thearm |81. The feedback pulses produced at the. arm of the .potentiometer I 65 -are coupled through' the condenser 88 -to the cable conductor I3 and fed back-to.the-subsuriaoe-unit iii.

In the subsurfaceequipment I0,l thefeedback pulses are applied-Ito a-pulse-rectier-circuit 55 (Fig. 2). and. arecoupled through the condenser 9310 the diode rectifiers 94 and 95 through the series connectednbias potential-sources ii'andf el. 'I'he condenser 93 blocksall of theunidirectional signals .present on the .conductor I3. If desired band elimination filters, indicatedgenerally at IIS, maybe providedaheadofthe pulse rectifier circuit 55 to suppress the lowfrequency error 1. signals and the. carrier frequency waves transmitted over .the conductor I3 tov the surfaceequipment II inthe. manner described above.

The rectiiier and bias .Voltage combinations act as threshold devices to eliminate any oversnoot which may occur: at the-trailing .edges of the feedback pulses. I due to charging of the condenser 93 :during the interval-of the pulses.- Also, the rectiersSl and 95 rectifly-the feedback-pulsesl to produce across. the output condenser'Sil'of the rectifier circuit 55, -a unidirectional feedbackvoltagevwhichvin amplitude. is-.proportional to the amplitude. of.the;feedback.pulses Ili'and has a polarity which corresponds--to the polarityof these puls es;;-; The potentia-Lacross-.the condensery 98 f-producs `a: fiowi-of Tour-rent throughtheffeed back load resistor 9| iwhichbalancessthe.- poi tental across the resistor-ileso that the-system is brought toanv accurate-balance. If the unie directional current Which-flows through th'erefsistor Sii Varies in either'directio'm-a LiO-cycle error signal is produced by the condenser-commutator circuit '35 fin the manner described above. This signal is fed to the surface-equipment toef-i fect readjustment lof the-potentiometer Iand feedback pulses ofcorresponding amplitude-and polarity are fedback over the conductor -I Sito-the pulse rectifier circuit -jlwherein theyare--recti-= ed to produce a corresponding unidirectional feedback current -flow throughA the resistor 19|;` thereby to balance the system.

It Will thus be evident that 'the neutron signal transmission facilities include afeedbacksys- `tem wherein feedback-pulses proportional: in arnplitude and polarity tothe position of the-neutron recording pen are derived from the generator |98, transmitted over-thecable I2, and rectified to produce a unidirectional feedback; potential which is used to balance the system.

The collar finder circuit-'2li may comprise any suitable circuit arrangement-for producingu'ni'- directional voltage uctuations in response to the traversal of casing collars by the subsurface unit In the embodiment'illustratedlfin- Fig.;- 2, the collar finder circuit -24 "comprises asirple permanent magnet |20 -upon-whichi is wound av coil I2! which is connected-l at Lone-end Vthrough the condenser I 22 to the conductor-I 3 and at the' other end to ground. Wheneverthe'magnet--IED passes a casing collar, the reluctance -of the-magnetic circuit is altered-'and a-unidirectionalvolt-'- age kick or fluctuation is generated Which is' cou-l pled through the condenser |22 to the conductor I3 and transmitted to vthe-earths vsurface.y Inrthe surface equipment the unidirectional voltage kicks are filtered in the-collar finder detector circuit 2I and impressed vupon the recorden 22,1 thereby to produce correlated collar position information on the record'chart 22a.

Simultaneous gamma'ray and neutron loggingmay also be accomplished by-means-of thealternative embodiment of the invention shownin detail in Figs. 4 andy 5.- Referring to these-figures, the gamma ray signal channel SI' (Fig. 4l and the gamma-ray detector channel' I0 (Fim-5)- are indentical with the corresponding units shown in Figs. 2 and 3 and function to provide a continuous log'n ofthe-,gamma yray activity *by movement of the recording pen V50. The neutron signal channelz andthe neutron detector channel 21 of Figs; i and -5 also are the same-in many respects -as the corresponding-units ofv the system shown in Figs.- Zand 3; However, inthe neutron channel of Figs-'fi and 5, the feedback voltage is in the form of 'a sine-wave-which is fedback to the subsurface-unit `Ill along with a-rixed phase referencesignal', which is modulated on a carrier wave of different frequency. Y

More specifically, inthe alternative-system of-` Figs. 4 and 5, the slide wire-potentiometer-I82 (Fig. 5) is energized-why'- means of an 800- cycle sine wave oscillator- 200;- Accordingly, an- 800- cycle feedback signal is produced at the arm |81A of the slide wirepotention'oeterY ISS-which variesy inamplitude and phase inaccordance with-"the position of the recording pen-|80;v The 800cycle: feedback signal is coupledJthrough the condenser |88 to the cable-I2 andtransmitted -backtoV the subsurface unit III:y l

In order to provide1V an 800'A cycleexdtphase "15 rferenc'e signal which may be used as a standard for comparison with the 800 cycle feedback signal, the output of the oscillator 200 is modulated on a high frequency carrier wave having a frequency of the order of 4500 cycles per second. Thus, a 4500 cycle oscillator 202 is provided and the outputs of the oscillators 200 and 202 are supplied to a modulator 204 so as to provide in the output circuit thereof a 4500 cycle carrier wave which is modulated with the 800 cycle fixed phase reference signal. The output from the modulator 200 is connected to the cable conductor I3 `and transmits the modulated carrier wave to Ythe subsurface equipment IU. :equipment ID, the neutron signal channel 32 In the subsurface I(Fig. 4) includes a band pass filter 2H) which :separates the 800 cycle feedback signal from the -other signals present on the cable conductor I3 Aand supplies the separated 800 cycle feedback signal through the coupling transformer 2I2 to a ring modulator circuit 220. The neutron signal channel S2 also includes a band pass filter 2 I 5 which separates the 4500 cycle modulated carrier wave from the other signals of the system and supplies the separated carrier wave through the coupling transformer 2 I4 to the detector ZIQ. The detector ZIB demodulates the separated 4500 cycle signal so as to provide an 800 cycle phase reference signal which is also supplied to the ring modulator circuit 220. The ring modulator circuit 220 functions in a manner identical to the ring modulator circuit M described in detail in connection with the gamma ray detector channel I9 (Fig. 3) and provides a unidirectional feedback voltage which is supplied to the feedback load resistor SI to complete the feedback loop of the system. i

In the event it is desired to provide a simplified system for simultaneously obtaining a neutron and gamma ray log, the system of Fig. 6 may be employed. In this system, the output from the gamma ray ionization chamber 25 and the neutron ionization chamber 21 are translated into alternating current signals by means of the condenser commutators 300 and SIB, which are L substantially identical with the condenser commutators 55 and 45 described in detail in connection with the system of Figs. 2 and 3. I-Iowever, in order to simplify the system, the stationary plates 12 (Fig. 2) of these commutators are connected directly to ground and no feedback system is employed. The ionization current of the gamma ray ionization chamber 25 is converted into a 75 cycle signal which is amplified in the amplifier 30I and transmitted over the cable l2 to the surface equipment II. At the surface, the 75 cycle signal is separated from the other signals of the system in' the band pass filter 302, amplified in the amplifier 353, and rectified in the rectifier 301i to produce a unidirectional output Voltage corresponding to the ionization current flowing through the resistor 06. The unidirectional output voltage is then supplied to one input circuit of the recorder 22.

In an entirely identical manner, the neutron ionization current is converted into a 40 cycle signal by means of the commutator SI5, amplified in the amplifier 3l I, transmitted over the cable I2 to the surface equipment II, separated fromV the other signals of the system in the band pass filter 3I2, amplied in the amplifier 3I3 and detected in the rectifier 3I4 to provide a unidirectional output voltage which is supplied to the other input circuit of the recorder 22. In l,this connection it will be understood that a collar finder circuit 24 and power supply 33 (Fig. 2)' and a collar finder detector circuit ZI (Fig. '5) may be employed in the system of Fig. 6 to sup-' ply power to the subsurface unit I0 and to provide correlated collar position information in the manner described in detail in connection with the systems of Figs. 2-5, inclusive.

While the alternative systems of the present invention have been described with reference to specific error and feedback signal frequencies, it will be understood that these frequencies are given merely for illustrative purposes and may vary from the values specified by a considerable amount. Thus, if desired, the frequency of the condenser commutators may be chosen in harmonic relation to the carrier oscillators, as described in the prior patent identified above.

While there have been described what are at present considered to be the preferred embodiments of the invention, it will be understood that various modifications may be made therein which are within the true spirit and scope of the invention as defined in the appended claims.

What is claimed as new and desired to be cured by Letters Patent of the United States is:

1. A radioactivity well logging system, comprising a subsurface unit, a cable having at least one insulated conductor for lowering said unit into a borehole, a first radiation detector included in said unit and adapted to produce a first signal in response to first radiations incoming to said unit, a second radiation detector ineluded in said unit and adapted to produce a second signal in response to second radiations incoming to said unit, and means including two mutually non-interfering self-balancing followup systems for transmitting over a conductor of said cable information representative of said first and second signals and for simultaneously logging at the earths surface the activity of said first and second radiations in the borehole.

2. A radioactivity well logging system, comprising a subsurface unit, a cable having at least one insulated conductor for lowering said unit into a borehole, a first radiation detector included in said unit and adapted to produce a first signal in response to gamma ray radiations intercepted thereby, a second radiation detector included in said unit and adapted to produce a second signal in response to neutrons intercepted thereby, two mutually non-interfering self-balancing follow-up systems commonly including a c onductor of said cable for transmitting said signals to the earths surface, and means at the earths surface controlled in accordance with the operation of said follow-up systems for simultaneously logging the gamma ray and neutron activity in said borehole.

3. A radioactivity well logging system, comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a first radiation detector included in said unit and adapted to produce a rst signal in response to first incoming radiations, a second radiation detector included in said unit and adapted to produce a second signal in response to second incoming radiations, collar finder means included in said imit and operative to produce direct current fiuctuations in response to traversal of casing collars by said unit, means including two mutually non-interfering self-balancing followup systems for transmitting over the single conductor of said cable information representative of said first and second signals and said direct current fiuctuations and for simultaneously logi7 ging at the earths surface the activity of both said first and second radiations in the borehole and the casing collars traversed by said unit.

4. A radioactivity well logging system, comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a first ionization chamber included in said unit and operative to produce a first unidirectional current in response to first incoming radiations, a second ionization chamber included in said unit and operative to produce a second unidirectional current in response to second incoming radiations, recording means at the earths surface, and two mutually non-interfering follow-up systems commonly including the single conductor of said cable for controlling said recording means in accordance with said first and second unidirectional currents, thereby simultaneously to produce continuing indications of the variations of said first and second radiations within the borehole.

5. In a simultaneous radioactivity well logging system of the type employing a subsurface unit adapted to produce a nrst unidirectional current proportional to rst incoming radiations and a second unidirectional current proportional to second incoming radiations, the method of measuring at the earths surface both said unidirectional currents while utilizing a single conductor supporting cable for the subsurface unit, which comprises the steps of translating said unidirection currents into alternating currents of different frequencies, transmitting said alternating currents over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, separting said alternating currents from each other at the earths surface, and producing a continuous graph of said separated signals, thereby to provide correlated logs of said first and second radiations.

6. In a simultaneous radioactivity well logging system of the type employing a subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a borehole by means of a single conductor cable and providing a first unidirectional current representative of first incoming radiations, and a second unidirectional current representative of second incoming radiations, the method of measuring at the earths surface both said unidirectional currents which comprises the steps of, converting by means of condenser oommutators said unidirectional currents into alternating currents of different frequencies, transmitting said alternating currents of different frequencies over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, separating said alternating currents from each other at the earths surface, rectifying each of said separated currents, and producing a continuous graph of said rectified currents, thereby simultaneously to provide correlated logs of said first and second radiations.

7. In a simultaneous neutron and gamma ray well logging system of the type employing a subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a borehole by means of a single conductor cable and providing a first unidirectional current representative of gamma radiation intercepted by the unit and a second unidirectional current representative of neutrons intercepted by the unit, the method of simultaneously measuring both said unidirectional currents at the earths surface which comprises the steps of transmitting a rst alternating current error signal of given frequency and indicative of changes in said first unidirectional current together with a xed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the nu' i single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a unidirectional voltage to balance changes in said first unidirectional current and reduce said error signal to Zero, transmitting a second alternating current error signal of dinerent frequency and indicative of changes in said second unidirectional `current together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, and feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a feedback wave representative of the amplitude and phase of said second error signal, thereby to balance changes in said second unidirectional current and reduce said second error signal to zero.

8. In a simultaneous radioactivity well logging system of the type employing a subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a borehole by means of a single conductor cable and providing a first unidirectional current representative of rst incoming radiations and a second unidirectional current representative of second incoming radiations, the method of simultaneously measuring both said unidirectional currents at the earths surface which comprises the steps of, transmitting a first alternating current error signal of given frequency and indicative of changes in said first unidirectional current together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a unidirectional voltage to balance changes in said first unidirectional current and reduce said error signal to zero, transmitting a second alternating current error signal of different frequency and indicative of changes in said second unidirectional current together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, and feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a pulse wave having an amplitude and polarity corresponding to the amplitudeand phase of said second error signal, thereby to balance changes in said second unidirectional current and reduce said second error signal to zero.

9. In a simultaneous radioactivity well logging system of the type employinga subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a borehole by means of a single conductor cable and providing a rst unidirectional current representative of rst incoming radiations and a second unidirectional current representative of second incoming radiations, the method of simultaneously measuring both said unidirectional currents at the earths surface which comprises the steps of, transmitting a first alternating ycurrent error signal of given frequency and indicative of changes in said first imidirectional current together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, adjusting a first slide wire potentiometer inV accordance with said first error signal, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a unidirectional voltage proportional to the adjusted position of said potentiometer thereby to balance changes in said first unidirectional current and reduce said first error signal to zero, transmitting a second alternating current error signal of different frequency and indicative of changes in said second unidirectional current, together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, ad-

justinga second slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said second error signal, and feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a pulse wave having an amplitude and polarity corresponding to the adjusted position of said second potentiometer, thereby to balance changes in said second unidirectional current and reduce said second error signal to zero.

1(1).*In a simultaneous radioactivity well loglging system of the type employing a subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a borehole by means of a single conductor cable and providing a first unidirectional current representative of rst incoming rradiations and a second unidirectional current representative of second incoming radiations, the method of simultaneously measuring both said unidirectional currents at the earths surface which comprises the steps of, transmitting a first alternating current error signal of given frequency and indicative of changes Vin said first unidirectional current together ith a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable Ato the earths surface, adjusting a first slide Wire potentiometer inaccordance with said first error signal, feeding backl over the single conductor of said cable a unidirectional voltage proportional to the adjusted position of said potentiometer thereby to Ybalance changes in said first unidirectional current and reduce said iirst'error signal to zero, transmitting a second alternating current error signalV of different frequency and indicative of changes inY said second unidirectional current, together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single `conductor of said cable to the earths surface, adjusting a second Slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said second error signal, feeding back` over the single conductor of said cable a pulse wave having an amplitude and polarity corresponding to the adjustedY position of said second potentiometer, and rectifying said feedback pulse wave to produce a unidirectional potential for balancing changes in said second unidirectional current, thereby to reduce said second signal, of given frequency and indicative of changes in said first unidirectional current together with a nxed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface', Vadjusting a first slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said first error signal, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable'a'unidirectional voltage proportional to the adjusted position of said potentiometer thereby to balance chengesdin said first unidirectional current and reduce said first error signal to zero, transmitting a second alternating current error signal of different frequency and indicative of changes in said second-unidirectional current, together with a fixed phase reference signal of the'same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, adjusting a second slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said second error signal, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable an alternating current signal having an amplitude and phase corresponding-to the adjusted position of said second potentiometer and of a frequency different from the other signals of the system together with a fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency, and deriving in said unit a unidirectional potential proportional to said alternating current signal for balancing changes in said second unidirectional current, thereby to reduce said second error signal to zero.

l2. In a simultaneous radioactivity well 10gging system of the type employing a subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a boreholek by means of a single conductor cable and providing a first unidirectional current representative of first incoming radiations and a second unidirectional current representative of second incoming radiations, the method of simultaneously measuring both said unidirectional currents at the earths surface which comprises the steps of, transmitting a rst alternating current error signal of given frequency and indicative of changes in said first unidirectional current together with a first fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor cable to the earths surface, said first fixed phase reference signal being modulated on a first carrier wavey ofgiven frequency, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a unidirectional voltage to balance changes in said first unidirectional current` and reduce said error signal to zero, transmitting a second alternating current error signal of different frequency and indicative of changes in said Ysecond unidirectional current together with a second fixed phase reference signal of thesame frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earthssurface, said secondfixed phase reference signal being modulated on a second carrier wave of different frequency, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a pulse Wave having an amplitude and polarity corresponding to the amplitude and phase of said error signal, thereby to balance changes in said second unidirectional current and reduce said second error signal to Zero.

' 13. Iny a simultaneous radioactivity well logging system ofthe type employing a subsurface unit adapted to be lowered into a borehole by means of a single conductor cable and providing a first unidirectional current-representative of first incoming radiations and a second unidirectional current representative of second incoming radiations, the method of simultaneously measuring both said unidirectional currents at the earths surface comprising the steps of, transmitting a first alternating current error signal of given freouency and indicative of changes in said first unidirectional current together with a first fixed phase reference signal of -the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable tothe Yearths surface, said first fixed phase reference signal being modulated on a first carrier Wave ofgiven frequencygadiusting a first slide Wire potentiometer in accordance with said firsterror signal, feeding back over the single conductor of said cable a unidirectional voltage proportional Vto the adjusted position of said potentiometer indicative of changes in said second unidirectional current, together with a second fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency over the single conductor of said cable to the earths surface, said second fixed phase reference signal being modulated on a second carrier wave of different frequency, adjusting a second slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said second error signal, and feeding back over the single conductor of said cable an alternating current signal having an amplitude and phase corresponding to the adjusted position of said second potentiometer and of a frequency different from the other signals of the system together with a third fixed phase reference signal of the same frequency, said third fixed phase reference signal being modulated on a third carrier wave of a frequency different from said other carrier Waves, deriving in said unit a unidirectional potential having an amplitude and polarity corresponding to the amplitude and phase of said feedback alternating current signal for balancing changes in said second unidirectional current, thereby to reduce said second error signal to zero.

14. A radioactivity Well logging system comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a iirst ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a first unidirectional current in response to first incoming radiationsy a second ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a second unidirectional current in response to second incoming radiations, means included in said unit for translating each of said unidirectional currents into alternating currents of diiferent frequencies, means including the single conductor of said cable for v transmitting said alternating currents to the earths surface, and means at the earths surface and responsive to said alternating currents for logging the activity of said first and second radiations in the borehole.

15. A radioactivity well logging system comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a first ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a first unidirectional current in response to gamma radiation intercepted thereby, a second ionization chamber included in said unit and operative to produce a second unidirectional current in response to neutrons intercepted thereby, means included in said unit for translating said unidirectional currents into alternating currents of different frequencies, means including the single conductor of said cable for transmitting said alternating currents to the earths surface, means at the earths surface for separating said alternating currents from each other, and means responsive to said separated currents for logging the neutron and gamma ray activity in the borehole.

16. A radioactivity well logging system comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a first ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a iirst unidirectional current in response to first incoming radiations, a second ionization chamber included in said unit and operative to produce a second unidirectional current in response to second incoming radiations, means included in said unit for translating said unidirectional currents into alternating currents of different frequencies, collar finder means included in said unit and operative to produce direct current iiuctuations in response to traversal of casing collars by said unit, means including the single conductor of said cable for transmitting said alternating currents and said direct current iiuctuations to the earths surface, and means at the earths surface and responsive to said alternating currents and said direct current fluctuations for simultaneously producing continuing indications of the activity of said first and second radiations in the borehole and the casing collars traversed by said unit.

17. A radioactivity well logging system, comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a rst ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a first unidirectional current in response lto first incoming radiations, a second ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a second unidirectional current in response to second incoming radiations, means included in said unit for translating each of said unidirectional currents into first and second alternating currents of different frequencies, means included in said unit for producing reference signals corresponding to each of said alternating currents, means including the single conductor of said cable for transmitting I ,said alternating currents and said reference signals to the earths surface, means at the earths surface for comparing said first alternating current and the corresponding reference signal to obtain a first unidirectional control voltage, means at the earths surface for moving the arm of a first slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said rst control voltage, means for deriving a unidirectional feedback voltage corresponding .to the adjusted position of said rst potentiometer, means at the earths surface for comparing said second alternating current and the corresponding reference signal to obtain a second unidirectional control voltage, means f-or moving the arm of a second slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said second control voltage, means for deriving a periodic feedback Wave corresponding to the adjusted position of said second potentiometer, means including the single conductor of said cable for transmitting said feedback voltage and Said feedback wave to said subsurface unit, and means at the earths surface responsive to said control voltages for logging the activity of said first and second radiations in the borehole.

18. A radioactivity well logging system, comprising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable for lowering said unit into a borehole, a

vfirst ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a rst unidirectional current in response to first incoming radiations,

a second ionization chamber included in said unit and adapted to produce a second unidirectional current in response to second incoming radiations, means included in said unit for translating each of said unidirectional currents into first and second alternating currents of diiferent frequencies, means included in said unit for producing reference signals corresponding to each the arm of a first slide wire potentiometer in accordance with said rst control voltage, means for deriving a unidirectional feedback voltage corresponding to the adjusted position of said ir iii 22% .,rstiipotentiometerpmeansfat fthe -earths surface )for ccmparing'said :second alternating 'current -and'thefccrresponding"reference` signal to :obtain -affsecond `unidirectional".control voltage, -rneans r-frormovingv the'. arm-:cina second .slide .wire ,poten- `itiom'eter in .accordance Withsaid second vcontrol voltaga means., for 'deriving 1a :periodic feedback Wave corresponding t-o theaadjusted-jpositionof said second potentiometen'means including fthe single: conductor of .said cable for transmitting .fsaidfeedback voltage. andv said feedback .wave vto-.said..'subsu:cface Vunit,-means responsive to said ffeedback Avoltage :and said feedback Wave for acounteracting fsaidiirst and second unidirection- :ali currents, and means :at the earths surface responsive .to'saidrcontrol voltages for logging .thefia'ctivity of said first and second radiations :in .ther-borehole.

19..-A Yradioactivity*Wellzlogging system, com- -prising a subsurface. unit, a single conductor `cablerfor 4lowering said unit' intoa borehole, a :first ionization :chamber includedv in said .unit zand fiadaptedtoproduce Va rst unidirectional 'fcurrent :in response to rst incomingradiations. aasecond ionization chamber included in lsaid :unittandadapted .to produce a second unidirectional 'current .in 4response yto second incoming iradiations,:means*included in said unit for trans- .;lating each of said unidirectional'currents into rst' andrseccnd alternating currents of diierent 1tvrequencies,means .included in said unit for pro- ;ducingfreferenoe signals' corresponding Vto each f oftsaid alternatingcurrents, collar Viinder means includedfin'said unit. and operative to produce :direct current fuctuations iin` response to trav- A-ersalof casingV collars by said unit, means in- ;cluding the single nconductor Voi said cable ,for transmitting ,f said `alternating ,currents, said direct :current iiuctuations and saidsreference 4signals -to the learths surface, VAmeans atth'e earths surface @for comparing said.' first alter- Y:nat-ing current f'and the correspon-ding'reference :signal 'tot obtain aa first lunidirectional control `voltagepnsieans -atY thev earths surface for moving the-.arm of :a first slide wire 'potentiometer in accordance-With said first control voltage, lmeans .for derivingfa unidirectional feedback voltage Acorresponding tothe Vadjusted:position of1said rst potentiometer, means :at the earthsxsurface .for-comparing said secondalternating current Vand the corresponding.reference'signal-to obtain ,-:a .second unidirectional control voltage, means Vfor moving the arm-of a second slide'wirepoten- Y.tiometer in accordance with `said second control voltage, means for deriving-a4 periodic feedback }wave.proportional in amplitudeand polarity to .theaadjusted .position of said second lpotenti ernsten-means including-the single .conductor of said cable for transmitting said feedback voltage yandsaid feedback-wave to said subsurface unit, .xandnmeans at the earths surface and responsive 11o-said control voltages and said direct current fluctuations for simultaneously producingA continuing indications of the activity of said first and second radiations in the borehole and casing .collar position. Y

20. A radioactivity -well logging system, com- --prising a subsurface unit, a single conductor cable `for, lowering said unit intoa borehole, a iirst ionization chamber included in said unit and adapt- .ed to produce a rst unidirectional current in re- ,.sponse to-rst incoming radiations, a second ion- .ization chamber included in said unit'and adapted to produce a second unidirectional current in zresponsefto second incoming radiations, means :included .insaid `unit f r :producing aiirstialternating' current error signal of A given lfrequency fdicative ofchanges l'in said rst. unidirectional ,current vand for producing a rst xed-phase reference 'signal of the same frequency, .means-in- `eluded in-saidvunitfor producing asecondalter- .nating currenterrorfsignalof different frequency :indicative of changes in said second unidirectional current and -for producing a second vfixed vphase'referencesignal vof VVthe Vsame frequency, -means includingf'the` single 1conductor of said ycable for transmittingfsaid signalsto thecarths surface, fmeans atA the earths surface for comfparing said yfirst error signal andsaid ffirst reference-signal fto vobtain a frst unidirectional con- :trol lvoltage, fmeans .at the 'earths surfacefor comparingsaid second errorsignal and `saidsec- .ond reference signalto obtainasecondunidirec- `Ational control voltage, iirst slide Wire potentiom- --eterI 'recording means adjustable by means of said rst. control voltage, second slide Wire-po- .tentiometer recording .means :adjustable-by means of said 'second Acontrol voltage,nf1eans -for deriv- -ing fromsaid ni-lrst potentiometer a funidirectional feedbackpotential proportional in amplitude and polarityto the adjusted position of saidfirst 7potentiometer, means forfderiving-fromsaid-second potentiometer a feedback 'pulse Wave having an amplitude and polarity corresponding vto the Aadjusted position -of -said second potentiometer, .means including the single conductor foi :said cable for'feeding back said' feedback vpotential .andsaid feedback wave tosaid` subsurface unit, :and `means :includedinsaid unitand responsive Ato saidfeedback potentialandv said feedback .Wave for reducing-said first' second erron signals .-to zero.

21. A radioactivity IWell floggingrsystem, comprisinga subsurface unit,a-single'conductor cable for lowering said unitdnto faboreholeya'rst l.ionization chamber' included finrsa'id unitand -,adap`ted `to, :produce a' 'first Iunidirectional current :in response .to -irst incoming radiations, a second :ionization 'chamber included fin said unit 'fand -adaptedrtoapro'duce a'second 'unidirectional cur- .rent-inresponse'to second incoming radiations, #means included in said unit'forproducinga i'st ffalternatingccurrent :errorsignal of 'given s frefezquency ,indicative `of changes-in said .rst -uniz. directional currentand for :producing a krst -iixed :phasereference signal of the ysame -frequency, `:means included in"saidunitfor'producing afsec- 'ond alternating current verror signal of different f'freduency'findicative of changes Ainl said second unidirectional Jcurrent yand for producing -a sec- :fond'xed phasereference signalrof' the same frequencyycollar iinder'means'included in said unit "and-operative to produce direct current iiuctuations in responseto traversal of casingicollars by said funit, .means including the single con- 'fductor'foi said'fcable for transmitting said signals fand'saiddirectcurrent fluctuations to the earths ksurface, means at the earths surface "forv comparing saidfrst error signal and said first ref- Aerence'signal to' obtain 4'a first unidirectional con- -trol fvoltage, means Aatt-lie `earth-s"surface `:for comparing said seconderror signalandsai'd sec- 'ondireferencesignal to obtain a second unidirec- Ltional control-voltage; first slide wirey potentiometermeans adjustable bymeansiof saidrst control voltage, "second :slide HWire potentiometer means adjustable byimeans of said second con trol-voltage,imeans for deriving from saidY first i potentiometer :a yunidirectional rfeedback potential :proportional .zin :amplitude *and polarity Ito 25 the adjusted position of said first potentiometer, means for deriving from said second potentiometer a feedback pulse Wave having an amplitude and polarity corresponding to the adjusted position of said second potentiometer, means including the single conductor of said cable for feeding back said feedback potential and said feedback wave to said subsurface unit, means included in said unit and responsive to said feedback potential and said feedback Wave for reducing said first and second error signals to zero, and means at the earths surface and responsive to said control voltages and said direct current fluctuations for simultaneously producing continuing indications of the activity of said first and second radiations in the borehole and the position of traversed casing collars.

SERGE A. SCHERBATSKOY.

References Cited in the le of this patent UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name Date 2,469,463 Russell May 10, 1949 10 2,481,014 Herzog Sept. 6, 1949 2,504,888 Siegert Apr. 18, 1950 2,558,427 Fagan June 26, 1951 

